RRconservative Heres a healthy dose of reality.
The Dems are listening to Military leaders who aren't puppets of the Bush admin.
ABIZAID: Senator McCain, I met with every divisional commander, General Casey, the core commander, General Dempsey, we all talked together. And I
said, in your professional opinion, if we were to bring in more American Troops now, does it add considerably to our ability to achieve success in
Iraq? And they all said no. And the reason is because we want the Iraqis to do more. It is easy for the Iraqis to rely upon to us do this work. I
believe that more American forces prevent the Iraqis from doing more, from taking more responsibility for their own future
Link
McCain is gambling that by 2008 coalition involvement in Iraq will have or be close to an end. McCain will be able to supporters of the status quo
"if more troops had been send this wouldn't have happened."
Bush is using a call for a troop increase in Iraq to deflect any calls from the Dems for a withdrawal.
Even supporters of the status quo don't support a troop increase.
Adding ten or twenty thousand more U.S. combat troops – mostly soldiers and Marines – isn't going to improve Iraqi willingness to fight their own
fight – an imperative if we are to claim victory in this war. While putting 200,000 American or NATO troops on the Iranian and Syrian borders to
stop infiltration might make sense, that's "mission impossible" given the size of U.S. and allied armed forces.
A "short-duration surge" in U.S. combat strength also ignores progress that is being made on the ground in places like Al Anbar province – where
few of the so-called mainstream media dare to spend much time. In Ramadi, long a hotbed of Sunni terrorism – new National and Provincial police
forces are increasingly effective. Calling themselves "The Sons of Al Anbar" – thousands of young Iraqi males have volunteered to defend their
cities, villages, homes and families from terrorists.
Link
More troops in Iraq would nothing but provide more targets for the insurgents and increase the casualty rate.